Larissa Behrendt, After story (#BookReview)

Larissa Behrendt’s latest novel After story has been on my wishlist since it came out last year, so I was thrilled when my reading group chose it as our 2022 NAIDOC-Week read. What self-respecting reader, after all, doesn’t like a literary tour?

After story, for those who haven’t caught up with it yet, is framed around a ten-day literary tour of England that is undertaken by a First Nations Australian mother and daughter, Della and Jasmine, whose relationship is fraught. Through this plot device, Behrendt marries her two storytelling loves – English literature and Indigenous Australian storytelling. In doing so, she draws comparisons between them, and explores ways in which both can reflect on and enhance our lives. She also shows how travel can be an engine of change for people.

Although it contains some very dark matter concerning grief and abuse, After story is a gentle and generous read – for two reasons. First, there’s the characters. Della and Jasmine, are strong, thoughtful and, importantly, real. Both have made mistakes in managing the challenges in their lives, but both genuinely want to have better relationships with those they love. Della, the less educated and more naive of the two, is particularly engaging for her honesty and lack of pretension, for her open-mindedness, and for the rawness of her pain. The other reason is the novel’s tone. It is clear and passionate about the wrongs done to Australia’s First Nations peoples but it is not angry. This is not to say that anger doesn’t have its place – it certainly does – but it’s not the only approach to telling the story of dispossession and dislocation.

What is particularly striking about this book is its structure and voice. After a prologue in Della’s voice telling of the disappearance twenty-five years ago of her 7-year-old daughter Brittany, the novel is structured by the tour, with each day being told, in first person, by Della and then Jasmine, until Day 8, when Della’s built-up grief overcomes her. After that, the order changes and Jasmine goes first. This change marks a turning point in their relationship – albeit not an immediate, epiphanic one. It also jolts the narrative out of a pattern that had risked becoming a little too rigorous. Like a coda, it makes the reader sit up and wonder what will happen next?

What does happen, however, as I’ve already implied, is not particularly dramatic. Rather, this book emulates something Virginia Woolf said, as Jasmine shares:

The great revelation perhaps never did come. Instead, there were little daily miracles, illuminations, matches struck unexpectedly in the dark.

Like life.

But, back to the structure. After story is one of those books in which the structure mirrors or supports its intention – and Jasmine, again, explains it well. Talking about Jane Eyre and Jean Rhys’ response to it in Wide Sargasso Sea, she says, “it’s compelling, the uncovering of the other side of the story”. “Uncovering the other side of the story” is the nub of this novel – personally, in terms of Della, Jasmine, and their relationship with each other and the rest of their family, and politically, in terms of the conflicting views and experiences of the colonisers and colonised. What Behrendt aims for in this novel, I believe, is to bring people together through improved mutual understanding.

Lest this sound too earnest, though, let me reiterate my earlier comment that this novel has a light touch. To balance the heavy material, which includes a number of losses including those related to abandoned and lost children, Behrendt creates a cast of typical tour participants. There’s the white male know-it-all professor and his seemingly mouse-like wife; the feminist young lesbian couple willing to take him on at every turn; the recently retired, educated middle-class couple; the bossy woman and her down-trodden sister; Della and Jasmine; and of course Lionel, the long-suffering tour guide, and bus-driver Brett. Behrendt handles these almost-stereotypical characters well, so that, by the end, even the arrogant Professor Finn is softened for us.

There is much humour in the telling, such as this, for example, from Della as she enters the British Museum, which, she has just discovered, still holds Aboriginal remains:

As we walked into the imposing white building there was a big glass bowl with money in it and a sign asking for donations.
“We already gave,” I said to the guard who was standing next to it.

Comments and asides like this are used throughout the novel to draw our attention to the truths we may not otherwise see. Truth, in fact, is a recurring idea in the novel – the withholding and the sharing. Della, reflecting on Thomas Hardy’s first wife being written out of history, remembers stories of erasure told by her community’s elder Aunty Elaine, and thinks “Sometimes the truth matters and you shouldn’t try to hide the facts”. A little later, Jasmine is also reminded of Aunty Elaine’s wisdom:

Aunty Elaine would remind me that there is more than one way to tell a story; there can sometimes be more than one truth. ‘The silences are as important as the words,’ she’d often say. There is what’s not in the archive, not in the history books – those things that have been excluded hidden overlooked.

Throughout the novel, Aunty Elaine’s stories and wisdom, shared through the memories of Della and Jasmine, provide the First Nations’ foil to the literary tour, sometimes enhancing, sometimes counteracting the messages and lessons of English literature.

I did, however, have one issue with the novel, one shared by a few in my reading group. This concerned its occasional didactic tone. Frequently, for example, the characters tell us what they’d learnt at various sites, such as about Jane Austen’s life or Virginia Woolf’s death. While we could see the point, the way the information was imparted did feel teachy at times. Fortunately, this tone did not extend to the novel’s underpinning ideas which are conveyed through the narrative rather than “told”.

In a Sydney Writers’ Festival panel, Behrendt said something that appeals to me, which is that the goal of being a great writer is to say something important. In After story, she has written an engaging, accessible novel, that also says important things – some subtle, some more overt, but all stemming, ultimately, from the traumas First Nations people have suffered, and continue to suffer, at the hands of the settlers.

Jasmine comes to a significant realisation near the end:

Suddenly I found the museum stuffy. When Aunty Elaine would talk about it, our culture felt alive – the sewing of possum cloaks … the gift of telling stories. They were living and breathing, not relics of the past, frozen in time. Looking at the artefacts surrounding me, I couldn’t help but feel I missed an opportunity with Aunty Elaine to capture her knowledge.

She had, she continues, “rightly valued education” but she had also “taken Aunty Elaine and her knowledge for granted”.

This is the call Behrendt makes in her novel. She wants both cultures given equal respect for what they can offer us. She knows the value of stories in bringing people together. Wouldn’t it be great if her story here achieved just that?

Larissa Behrendt is a Eualeyai/Kamillaroi woman

This book has been reviewed by several bloggers including Lisa, Brona and Kimbofo.

Larissa Behrendt
After story
St Lucia: UQP, 2021
ISBN: 9780702263316

20 thoughts on “Larissa Behrendt, After story (#BookReview)

  1. A terrific book, and great for a book group to unpack.
    My most memorable character was Della, especially when she arced up against Jasmine telling her what to do. Very authentic!

  2. I am reading Mark Mckenna’s 2002 (and updated 2014) Looking for Blackfellas’ Point. Re his uncovering of the south coast Yuin story after he had purchased land at Towamba – inland from Twofold Bay. Mark wrote Return to Uluru – the uncovering of the murderer of the Arrernte man Yokununna in the early 1930s at Uluru. The 2002 book deals with what happened in that region snd vigorously interrogates the benign and untruthful stories – the myths – of invader “settlement” etc. I haven’t read After Story – but there are themes in Mark McKenna’s book which LB seems to be touching on according to your review. Thanks.

    • Thanks Jim. Yes, I know Mark McKenna having read Return to Uluru, but haven’t read Blackfellas’ Point. I think Behrendt synthesises a lot of ideas and thoughts in After story. I’m sure you’d enjoy it.

  3. This group travelling around and the loss and the first-nation’s perspective all remind me of The Prairie Chicken Dance Tour, a relatively newer book out of Canada by Dawn Dumont. As you described what happened in the novel I kept recalling moments from Dumont’s book. Interesting that they both chose a tour of some sort to move the characters around and learn things.

    • Great Angela. You’re like I was. It’s a book with so many ideas and neat connections. I had a whole list but, you know, you can’t say it all in a post. I think this is why the other bloggers’ reviews all vary quite a bit. Of course there’s a core because the main idea comes through but there’s so much in it. My group had a great discussion and it speared off into some political discussion too which I think would please Behrendt.

  4. I imagine that including facts in a novel is difficult to master without that ‘teachy’ impression.
    How to do both is well beyond moi !!

    • Yes, that’s what we discussed in reading group M-R. She gave it a red hot shot … part of it I think was that there was very little new for some of us. We know the biographies of those icons, and we also know Bruce Pascoe’s etc history of First Nations agriculture and aquaculture practices.

  5. What a unique and poignant story! Love this quote: “The great revelation perhaps never did come. Instead, there were little daily miracles, illuminations, matches struck unexpectedly in the dark.” Talking about First Nations, did you know that The Pope was in Canada this past weekend, my province Alberta and Quebec to be specific, for the purpose of delivering his apology to the First Nations people for the tragic operation of residential schools by the Catholic Church in the past.

    • Thanks Arti. I love that you like that quote too. It’s so good … Virginia Woolf was so good!

      Yes, we had heard that on the news. Every step of recognition helps I think.

      • Yes, that’s a VW quote and not from the book. But still poignant. BTW, a lot of children were labelled ‘missing’ at residential schools here in Canada, but what was horrific is now they’re digging up thousands of human remains on the sites of these residential schools. That’s the major factor prodding the Pope to come to apologize. I think that’s quite something for him to do this.

  6. Thanks for the link, Sue. I enjoyed this novel a lot but like your book group criticisms I did find the info on the literary sites / literary figures a bit like Wikipedia entries that had been shoehorned in (and said this in my review), but on the whole this was a wonderful book.

    • Thanks kimbofo How did I miss that in your review – I must read it again! I was rushing to finish my review that did just skim read those I was linking to. I’m glad, though, that I’m not the only one. As you say though it’s still a great read.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s