Quite by coincidence, I read Evie Wyld’s second novel All the birds, singing straight after Eleanor Catton’s The luminaries. I was intrigued by some similarities – both have a mystery at their core, and both use a complex narrative structure – but enjoyed their differences. Wyld’s book is tightly focused on one main character while Catton’s sprawls (albeit in a very controlled way) across a large cast. Paradoxically, Wyld’s 230-page book spans a couple of decades while Catton’s 830-page one barely more than a year. And yet both convey, through their structures, an idea of circularity, of the close relationship between beginnings and endings. But, enough prologue. On with All the birds singing.
The book opens powerfully:
Another sheep, mangled and bled out, her innards not yet crusting and the vapours rising from her like a steamed pudding. Crows, their beaks shining, strutting and rasping, and when I waved my stick they flew to the trees and watched, flaring our their wings, singing, if you could call it that. I shoved my boot in Dog’s face to stop him from taking a string of her away with him as a souvenir, and he kept close by my side as I wheeled the carcass out of the field and down into the woolshed.
And so we are introduced to Jake and the things that dominate her life – Dog, sheep and birds. Soon, we learn there’s another thing – fear. But fear of what, or whom, we don’t know. From this opening, Wyld tells her story in alternating chapters: the odd ones, set in England, move forward, and the even ones, in Australia, move back to what started it all. It’s an effective structure that explores the ongoing impact on Jake of whatever it was that happened. We see what’s happening now, and we slowly see how she has got to this point.
Jake, at the start of the novel, is in her 30s. She’s a loner, capably running a sheep farm on a remote British island. Her nearest neighbour, Don, keeps a bit of a fatherly eye on her, and tries to encourage her to engage with the local community, to go to the pub for example, but Jake is not interested. As we move back in time we learn snippets about various significant people in her life – a lover while she was a shearer, a controlling man whom she’d initially seen as her rescuer, a female friend and co-worker. We also learn that she’s estranged from her Australian family, and we discover that she has scars on her back, but how they were caused are part of the mystery.
Wyld’s writing is marvellous. The imagery is strong but not heavy-handed because it blends into the story. The rhythm changes to suit the mood. The plot contains parallels that you gradually realise are pointing the way. There’s humour and irony. I love the fact that our Jake, on the run from whatever it is, smokes “Holiday” brand cigarettes.
There’s a bleakness to the novel, but it’s not unremitting. Jake, always the outsider, is tough and resourceful. She sleeps with a hammer under her pillow, but she has a soft side that is revealed mostly through her tenderness towards her animals. She talks to Dog, and losing a sheep always brings “a dull thudding ache”. The imagery is focused. Black, shadows, and fire in various permutations recur throughout the novel. They provide possible clues to what started it all; they contribute to the menace she feels now; and they help create an unsettling tone for the reader. We are never quite sure whether the shadow she sees out there, watching, following her, is real or a figment of her imagination. Jake is not an unreliable narrator, but we see through her eyes, and her eyes are influenced by her very real fears. She is “damaged goods”, though not in the sense meant by the paying customer (if you know what I mean!) offended by her scarred back.
And of course, there are the birds. They’re omnipresent. Sometimes they reflect her mood (“the birds sing and everything feels brand new”); sometimes they break tension; sometimes they suggest death. There are specific birds – butcher birds, night jars, galahs, merlins, currawongs and crows – and there are birds in general. The imagery references the real and metaphorical, from the crows hovering over the dead ewe in the opening paragraph to the birds near the end that attend the defining event:
[…] and the birds scream, they scream at me, Chip, chjjj, cheek, Jaay and jaay-jaay notes, Tool-ool, twiddle-dee, chi-chuwee, what-cheer … Wheet, wheet, wheet, wheet […]
It’s deafening. But it’s the silence and the dead birds afterwards that impresses the full horror on us:
The trees don’t want me there … There’s not a single bird to make a sound.
All the birds, singing is about how the past cannot “be left alone”. “We’ve all got pasts”, the shearers’ boss tells Jake early in the novel, but for some people the past must be dealt with before they can move on. The novel is also about redemption. It’s not the first novel about the subject, and neither will it be the last, but it is a finely told version that catches you in its grips and makes you feel you are reading it for the first time.
John at Musings of a Literary Dilettante loved the book too. Thanks to my brother and family for a wonderful Christmas gift!
All the birds, singing
North Sydney: Vintage Books, 2013
30 thoughts on “Evie Wyld, All the birds, singing (Review)”
This one I shall buy, with enormous interest. You’re a reviewer and a half, Sue!
Why thanks MR. i hope you enjoy it.
I have a review copy of this one, Gummie, but I won’t be reading it until closer to the publication date (April).
Ah I’ll be interested in what you say, Guy. It was published here last year, quite a few months ago.
I’m looking forward to reading this. I loved her first novel – rich language and tangible atmosphere, characters that lingered. Great review WG. Evie is also a generous writer and serious book lover – she stocks Pelt at her shop in Peckham!
I haven’t read her first Catherine, but that’s great to hear about her support.
Lovely review, Sue. It brought back some great memories of a fabulous novel. John
It is fabulous John, I agree.
Glad you enjoyed the book as much as we did. As soon as I read it I knew what your Christmas present would be. There were some fantastic novel by young Australian women novelists published last year.
You all done good Ian, thanks. Is there anything you’d like to add from your reading? There was so much to talk about.
I enjoyed reading your review; I recently finished this book and loved it. If you haven’t read her first novel, After the Fire, A Still Small Voice, I’d really recommend it!
Thanks Gemma, and welcome, I’m certainly interested to read it after this one.
I read this novel just after Christmas, and really enjoyed it. I thought it was quite Gothic, gloomy and mysterious. I loved the style of writing, and I am going to an Evie Wyld event (love her name), at the Wheeler Centre on 27 February, where she will discuss her book and ideas.
Thanks Meg … I tagged it as gothic but didn’t use the word in my review. I’d love to hear how the event goes. I love her name too. A great writer’s name. Looks good as well as being distinctive but easy to remember.
Pingback: Die Sonntagsleserin KW #06 – 2014 | buchpost
Oh, this sounds good! And isn’t it interesting how some authors can cover such long time periods in short books while others cover short times in very long books? It makes for some interesting stylistic choices too.
Oh heavens, that opening is incredible! What writing!
It’s pretty powerful, isn’t it, Hannah.
Pingback: Stella Prize 2014 Longlist Announced/Reviews Roundup | Australian Women Writers Challenge
That’s a great review WG. I see you picked the opening para to quote just as I did at mine, it’s very powerful isn’t it?
Lovely points on the use of the birds as symbols.
Thanks Max … Yes it’s a great opening.
Pingback: February 2014 Roundup: Classics and Literary | Australian Women Writers Challenge
Pingback: 2014 Miles Franklin Longlist | ANZ LitLovers LitBlog
I gave up on this–nothing to do with the writing itself but all the animal bashing became too much. I should have guessed as much from the cover.
Oh, that’s a shame Guy … But I understand. I seem to be able to separate fiction, and as I recollect the main character was caring about her animals.
Pingback: 2014 Mils Franklin Shortlist | ANZ LitLovers LitBlog
Pingback: 2014 Miles Franklin Shortlist | ANZ LitLovers LitBlog
Pingback: Evie Wyld wins 2014 Miles Franklin Literary Award for All the Birds, Singing. | Australian Women Writers Challenge
Pingback: February 2014 Roundup: Classics and Literary | New Australian Women Writers Challenge Blog
Pingback: All the Birds, Singing, Evie Wyld | theaustralianlegend