Leah Swann, Sheerwater (#BookReview)

Book cover

I’ve been wanting to read Leah Swann’s Sheerwater, having read and enjoyed, a few years ago, her short story collection, Bearings (my review). However, I didn’t get around to buying a copy, so was pleased to see it available as an audio book when I was looking for listening matter for our recent Melbourne trip. I thought we’d finish it on the trip but, in the end, the sightseeing was so interesting that we listened less than we thought we would. We’ve finished it now!

But, how to write about a crime book in which the main mystery – the disappearance of two boys – is resolved for us early on. At least, resolved in the sense that we discover what has happened to them and who was involved. As it turns out, though – and we learn this quickly – there’s another story to tell, and it’s a powerful, terrifying and unfortunately only too relevant one, a story of domestic violence, of power and control that isolates those who are vulnerable.

Interestingly, the novel’s opening reminded me strongly of the unforgettable opening to Ian McEwan’s Enduring love, which, as it happens, is also about dysfunctional love, albeit a different sort. There is also an ironic allusion to Australian literature’s “lost child” motif, when Ava thinks “this was a Continent where you could still get lost”, because these children aren’t “lost” – per se!

Anyhow, the story takes place over three days, and is told in alternating 3rd person voices, primarily those of the mother Ava, father Laurence, and 9-year-old Max who is the older of the two sons. Swann does an impressive job of getting into the heads of these disparate characters. Each one feels psychologically real, and their stories are compelling – well, most of their stories. Laurence is way too chilling to be compelling, but he is scarily real.

Now, I’m not going to write my usual sort of review, because listening to a novel (particularly while driving) doesn’t provide the same opportunity for reflection (and note-taking) that reading does, and certainly not for recording quotes, though I did jot down a few when I wasn’t the driver. The novel falls into the literary crime category, I’d say, for several reasons: it’s not a traditional crime novel; it’s told from multiple points of view; and the language is highly descriptive, if not poetic.

The title Sheerwater, for example, has multiple meanings. There’s the literal one, it being the name of the town that Ava is escaping to, and a literal and metaphorical one in that shearwaters (or, mutton birds), at the time the book is set, are doing their big migration south. They start the novel and each of the three days (if I remember correctly). There’s a sense that their impressive endurance mirrors that of women like Ava, and their arduous journey that of the boys. If we push it, there could also be a play on the words “sheer water” given the multiple meanings of “sheer” (pure, perfect, precipitous) and the role of water and the sea in the novel.

“We become evil when we hide the truth from ourselves” (Mother)

Swann creates a melancholic tone early on with phrases like “no pity under its wings”, and “sea of shipwrecks and stolen lives”. The no-nonsense but ultimately supportive policewoman Ballard is described by Ava as having a face like the “impermeable slap of seawashed stone”. It’s not all completely grim though. There is a lot of love, and Ava’s comment on one person’s kindness being enough to sustain a whole childhood is beautiful albeit, in a sense, prophetic.

So, was this book good to listen to? Yes, and no. Katherine Tonkin reads it well, including bursting into little verses of song when required. I didn’t find her voice intrusive, which can be a problem with audiobooks. However, for me, such highly descriptive books are better read than listened to. Somehow, when listening, there’s a greater sense of wanting to get on with the story. The descriptions and internal ruminations got in the way of that, whereas reading it would have allowed me to better absorb the language and descriptions, to feel and consider them, so I’m sorry about that.

Still, the narrative is strong, and it grabbed our attention, forcing us to think hard about each character, their truthfulness, their motivations, and the soundness of their actions. Who would you believe, and what would you do (if you were any of the characters involved), are the questions you confront as you read. The ending is also strong, emotional – and, dare I say it, appropriate.

In Sheerwater, Swann uses fiction to put flesh on the media stories we hear about domestic violence, encouraging us to see behind the stories to feel the confusion, roller-coaster emotions, helplessness and terror that those involved experience. Sheerwater is a book that says something.

Read for Reading Matters Southern Cross Crime Month

Challenge logo

Leah Swann
(Read by Katherine Tonkin)
Bolinda/HarperCollins Audio, 2020
8hrs 44min (Unabridged)
ISBN: 9781460782354

16 thoughts on “Leah Swann, Sheerwater (#BookReview)

  1. Snap! I’ve just finished this (but not yet reviewed it) and thought it was wonderful. The writing is so lush and poetic and the characterisation so rich and authentic I didn’t want the story to end. I loved being wrapped up in the events but found the ending a shock: I wanted something more hopeful. But I guess that made it more powerful and all too real.

    • Oh dear, kimbofo, my two contributions to your crime week, then, are books you’ve read! Oh well!

      I must say I was initially shocked too – and Mr Gums hated it – but then realised it was the “right” ending. (I loved the little dig at the media at the end there.)

  2. I’ve not yet got into audio books, but I do think I might when my work starts up again and I’m driving more. Would make a nice break from the news. This sounds really good

  3. Particularly interesting for me, even though your and my views on listening to stories are different: listening, for me, gives me every little bit that reading allowed me to skip ! Of course the narrator is key, and can make or break a book (Angus King, I love you !).
    Not sure about this book: I shall think about it. 😀

    • Ha ha, M-R but you can fast forward I presume! We tried listening to this as a bid-time story but would fall asleep. So much harder trying to find where you had dropped off than with a book!

  4. I agree with M-R. Listening, especially over long periods, makes you absorb every word. Listening in bed works less well, because I forget to pay attention. Though, at the end of a trip I will sometimes sit and listen to the end of a book rather than leave it to the next day when I might be doing deliveries and so on. I must say I’m sure I would struggle to concentrate with someone in the cab with me, I would tend to talk over the reader, want to discuss both things in the book, and passing by.

  5. Listening to books once you’re tucked in bed is impossible. The wife and I tried it. Made getting comfy in bed so much slower, as we’d skip from the start of the track trying to work out where we fell asleep.

    Listening while receiving home stuck in peak hour traffic was much better, and gave us a solid 40 minutes a day progress. For some reason, wasn’t quite so good going in to work. Maybe because we wanted to listen and relax.

    I’ve stopped listening to audio books, but the wife enjoys them while she is quilting.

    • All makes sense to me Neil. Also, with two, you have to both like reading the same thing. A bit like the days when we’d go to the video shop with the family to find a DVD for us all to watch! What a challenge that often was. I don’t do much sewing these days, but I can imagine audiobooks would be great for that.

  6. This sounds a good book to read. I listen to a lot of audio but am selective. Biographies, diaries and non fiction I think are best. A detailed novel needs to be the book. Unless someone like Clive James or David Sedaris. Travel writing I find is good as audio. Once in awhile I’ll listen to a book if it has a lot of foreign language or foreign names as I am able to hear the correct pronunciation. Think Russian. 🐧🌼

  7. Pingback: ‘Sheerwater’ by Leah Swann – Reading Matters

  8. Pingback: Southern Cross Crime Month wrap-up – Reading Matters

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s