Skip to content

Hobart Writers Festival 2019, Part 1: Guest post

September 16, 2019

No, I didn’t go to this year’s Hobart Writers Festival, but I had the next best thing – a brother who did. Not only that, but he responded positively to my request for some notes. I’ll be posting what he so-called “cobbled” together today and tomorrow, which means no Monday Musings this week. I hope – and believe – that you’ll find his report a worthy replacement.

By way of introduction, my brother Ian Terry has lived in Tasmania for well over three decades now, and recently retired after around 10 years as a curator of history at the Tasmanian Museum and Art Gallery. We have been discussing our reading most of our adult lives. It’s a connection that means a lot to me,  because I respect his thoughts and interpretations (despite his not being a Jane Austen fan!)

Part 1: Saturday 14 September

Tasmanian readers and writers have had a mixed week. On the cusp of publishing its 40thanniversary edition of the state’s well-regarded literary magazine, Island learned that its funding from Arts Tasmania has not been renewed for 2020. Unless it can find new sources of funding this celebratory issue will be the magazine’s last.

On a happier note Hobart’s historic Hadley’s Orient Hotel, in recent years positioning itself as a significant cultural space in the city, hosted the Hobart Writers Festival this weekend. The festival has a had a chequered history, sometimes held annually, sometimes bi-annually at varying venues and with changing names. This record suggests that while Tasmania takes its art and culture seriously and has a vibrant and important scene, the state’s small population creates recurring financial difficulties.

This festival’s theme, My Tasmanian Landscape, promised a program all about ‘Tasmania’s amazing literary landscape’ to celebrate ‘our diverse writers and writing’. While it is too long since I ventured into the Hobart Writers Festival, this edition did not disappoint with several sessions a balm to my historian’s soul offering me tempting choices.

Book coverOn the first morning Henry Reynolds was in conversation with Ian Broinowski, author of a historical fiction entitled The Pakana Voice: Tales of a War Correspondent from Lutruwita (Tasmania) 1814-1856. Broinowski whose grandfather and father were both editors of the local newspaper, The Mercury, invents a colonial journalist, W.C., reporting on the frontier war that raged in Tasmania, but with sympathies lying on the Aboriginal side of the frontier. W.C. writes his despatches from an Aboriginal point of view, upending the usual way of reading history and forcing us to consider the colonial experience from the other side of the frontier. Acknowledging that as a non-indigenous person he could not truly represent an Aboriginal voice, Broinowski consulted the well-known Tasmanian Aboriginal writer puralia meenamatta Jim Everett and began the session by thanking him for his assistance and for changing the way he thought about Tasmania’s history.

The conversation touched on many issues, particularly on language, representation and the free press, matters as pertinent today as in the early 19thcentury. W.C. has a trusty canine companion Bent, a nod to early Tasmanian newspaper editor, Andrew Bent, who is regarded as the founder of Australia’s free press for his strident opposition to government control of newspapers. Words and language, Reynolds reminded us, configure the way we regard our history, drawing attention, as an example, to the procession of 26 weapon-carrying Aboriginal men and women through Hobart in early 1832. Although usually portrayed as having surrendered to colonial power Reynolds observed that captives do not commonly proceed to a Governor’s residence spears in hand. Words matter.

In a moving finale, Broinowski asked readers of his book to think about the people depicted on its cover – Aboriginal Tasmanians as drawn by John Glover – as the original owners of the soil and victims of the violence of the frontier.

History underpinned the next session which saw the launch of the inaugural Van Diemen History Prize, initiated by Forty South Publishing, at the suggestion of historian Dr Kristyn Harman. Judges Kristyn Harman, Imogen Wegman and Nick Brodie joined winner Paige Gleeson and highly commended authors Tony Fenton and Terry Mulhern on a panel discussing history writing in general and the authors’ essays in particular.

Brodie observed that much of Tasmanian history could be categorised as myth, and commended Gleeson for exploring and exploding the much-repeated myth of a bunch of rowdy female convicts (the so-called Flash Mob) mooning Governor Sir John Franklin and his wife, Jane Lady Franklin, at the Cascade Female Factory in 1844. In her thoughtful and entertaining response, Gleeson noted that, as an academic historian, writing popular history was alien to her, so she consulted the seer of all modern knowledge, Google, to get some tips. ‘Do not write about historiography,’ she was sternly advised, ‘nobody wants to read about writing about writing history’. ‘Rubbish,’ she thought and proceeded to do just that, exploring how myths come into being and how, while not wholly accurate, they can hold kernels of truth that point to a larger social reality.

In similarly entertaining mode, Tony Fenton informed the audience that writing about the minutiae of weather, the environment and times encountered by hapless scientists who journeyed to Bruny Island and remote Port Davey to view the eclipse of the sun in May 1910 was critical to his story, because otherwise it would be boring ‘as nothing happened’. Four weeks of drizzle, rain and grey skies did not abate and the eclipse was impossible to see. School children in Queenstown, on the other hand, despite the town’s soggy reputation, enjoyed rapidly clearing skies and a good view of the event.

Terry Mulhern’s essay is more sombre, telling us of the last days, even hours of early 19thcentury Henry Hellyer who took his own life 1832. Mulhern told us that he was able to draw on his own early experience of depression to empathise with the turmoil that led Hellyer down his fatal path.

Finally, in answering a question from the floor, Imogen Wegman reminded us that historical myth-breaking takes courage and could be controversial. For female historians, she suggested, this is even more difficult as women were not meant to rock the boat.

My third session took me on a journey from 1820s India and Tasmania’s Derwent Valley to the state’s Fingal Valley in the 1930s as Henry Reynolds discussed the lives, nature writing and linkages between Elizabeth Fenton and her great great grand-daughter, Anne Page with Margaretta Pos. Pos, a former Mercury journalist and ‘plain writer’ in her own words, has written about Elizabeth Fenton and published the teen-aged journal of own mother Anne Page.

Both women wrote lyrically about Tasmania’s natural world. Page called herself a ‘bush rat’ and lovingly described the valley in which she lived with its presiding presence, Tasmania’s second highest peak Ben Lomond. She listed animals sighted, including the thylacine, and like Fenton decried the destruction of old growth forest and the environment in general.

Reynolds noted that while many historians have argued that it took several generations for Australians to grow a deep sense of place and love for their new home, in Tasmania this happened very quickly as evidenced by the writing of women such as Fenton. He also suggested that Page’s love of nature was fostered by her being educated at home on the Fingal Valley farm rather than at school where education focussed away from Tasmania.

In conclusion, Pos reported that she asked her mother, who died aged 97, whether she had ever wanted to write books. ‘I was going to write eight books,’ Anne Page replied, ‘but had eight children instead’.

Dissident poets and story-tellers Sarah Day, Cameron Hindrum, Pete Hay, Ruth Langford and Gina Mercer, rounded out my day one sessions by discussing the role of poets as activists. Hindrum stated that Tasmanians have a genetic predisposition ‘not to take any crap’ and quoted Bertolt Brecht who, writing about dictatorship, asked, ‘Why were their poets silent?’

Unconvinced by Brecht’s question, Hay, a poet, academic and activist, provocatively opined that poets puff themselves up, that with their tiny and declining audience they cannot be activist by writing alone. Poetry, he said, is elusive and enigmatic and so cannot be put to political cause, although he did concede that writers have a role to bear witness and cut through political sloganeering. He finished by telling us that poetry rewires the brain by bending the rules of language, and read a moving poem about driving through clear-felled land near Laughing Jack Lagoon in central Tasmania – It’s no laughing matter, Jack – the poem concluded.

Day countered Hay’s thesis by remembering the writer/poet/activist Judith Wright and quoting Emily Dickinson’ lines, Tell all the truth/but tell it slant. Mercer drew on her own history of childhood trauma telling the audience that poetry became her solace and her voice, her way of speaking the unspeakable, of being activist in the cause of women’s and environmental rights by transforming silence into words and action. She spoke of poetry as providing reflective activism.

Langford, a Yorta Yorta woman who grew up in Tasmania, confessed that she was a dissident by birth and a story-teller rather than a poet, and that she had engaged in much activism in her life, chaining herself to machinery and scaling corporate buildings to hang protest banners. Life as an activist she said was one of hate and division, of us and them. Now eschewing direct activism, she argued that our current predicament required intelligence to heal the planet and society, with words and poetry providing powerful vehicles for this.

32 Comments leave one →
  1. September 17, 2019 2:21 am

    Love the insights….especially about poetry.
    Your brother’s report has offered me some new
    authors to investigate!
    Thank you and your brother Ian!

    • September 17, 2019 8:05 am

      You’re welcome, N@ncy. There were certainly some interesting books discussed.

  2. Marie ZUVICH permalink
    September 17, 2019 7:58 am

    Well big thanks to Ian and to you Sue for asking him.
    After a 4 day stint in Hobart this winter exploring the city, its pubs and museums I’m inclined to make our next trip there coincide with their writer’s festival.
    Great report Ian. Cheers

    • September 17, 2019 8:07 am

      Thanks Marie. It would certainly be worth timing your visit that way. It was a very enjoyable couple of days.

    • September 17, 2019 10:31 am

      And I should do the same Marie. It’s a great place to visit, isn’t it!

  3. September 17, 2019 8:00 am

    I have missed the festival as I’m in Sydney and had booked it before I knew the dates. Thank your brother for me. I enjoyed his post.

    • September 17, 2019 10:31 am

      And there was another opportunity to serendipitously run into him Pam. One day!

  4. September 17, 2019 8:08 am

    Thanks TravellinPenguin, next time!

  5. September 17, 2019 9:42 am

    Good report Ian, you got to some interesting sessions. Sue knows that I am dubious about white writers writing from a Black perspective, however much they consult. But I don’t forget that much of our understanding was initiated by Henry Reynolds. Still, I’m mostly motivated to see what Everett has written. And I’m with Day, I think all people with prestige – writers rather than poets (mostly) these days – have a duty to speak up.

    • September 17, 2019 10:33 am

      Thanks Bill – I thought you’d accept this as a worthy replacement for Monday Musings, and would enjoy the issues Ian raised.

    • September 17, 2019 10:41 am

      Thanks Bill, yes they were interesting sessions. Ian Broinowski was very upfront about that issue and said that Jim Everett completely altered how he wrote the book. Also that JE was happy for him to write this book in the way he did with appropriate discussion with indigenous people. In my experience, Tasmanian Aboriginal people are supportive of non-Aboriginal writers/curators/artists working in a supportive way that does not stereotype or take authority away from their community. I think this last is critical and must include meaningful dialogue.

      • September 17, 2019 4:36 pm

        Thanks Ian . That’s the sense I have got from other indigenous people though of course it’s not universal. The point, as you say, is having the dialogue.

    • Ian Broinowski permalink
      September 22, 2019 8:21 pm

      Hi Wadhollaway
      You are absolutely correct about the issues of writing from an aboriginal perspective and I certainly did not do that. W.C. is a British war correspondent and has no pretensions of trying to write from any other perspective than his own. Thats the whole point its all about newspapers and how they covered the events in Tasmania during this period. I hope you find the book interesting.

      kind regards

      Ian

      • September 23, 2019 8:47 am

        Thanks Ian for joining in, and clarifying the perspective you used in your book.

  6. September 17, 2019 10:02 am

    Many thanks to your brother, especially for the info about The Pakana Voice. Puzzled about why I’d heard nothing about this book, I looked up its publishing details at Goodreads — alas, it seems to be self-published, with all the distribution problems that go with that. Amazon.au and Fishpond both have it for $38 (!) but Readings doesn’t have it at all, and I can’t find it at Fullers Bookshop in Hobart though they don’t have a search function on their website which doesn’t help! I can’t find a copy at any library in Victoria, which is the real pity because (given my experience with S-P books), I’d prefer to borrow it than buy it). But maybe the publicity from the HWF will make it more readily available…
    And this brings me back to funding for Tas writing… I can see that from a commercial publishers PoV, this book might not have Australia-wide appeal (except to nerds like me). I also suspect that the political question of appropriation might also influence the decisions of boutique publishers on the mainland, even though this book comes with an Indigenous imprimatur and the respect of no less a person than Henry Reynolds. Clearly there is a major role for the Tas government to play, but they can’t afford it. Their priorities lie in education, health and development, and while the amount of money to support the arts is small, the Tas budget is small. It seems to me that the Australia Council ought to be helping out here…

    • September 17, 2019 10:04 am

      Pity about Island – maybe they could have published this one instead of (as well as, even) the last David Ireland

      • September 17, 2019 10:13 am

        Oh, not instead of, surely! The World Repair Video Game was the best by David Ireland that I’ve read…

        • September 17, 2019 10:45 am

          The book is probably available at Fullers, Lisa, and is definitely available at Hobart Bookshop which provided the festival selling point. Chris (at Hobart Bookshop) was selling it for $55 and told me that it sold pretty well.
          With regard to the funding issue, Island has had the problem in the past and was bailed out by the Australia Council I think. As you rightly point out, Tasmania is a small state with a low capacity for funding everything it wants to. Nonetheless, the government does try to position it as a cultural destination, therefore …

        • September 17, 2019 4:43 pm

          Thanks Ian.

    • September 17, 2019 10:35 am

      Wow, Lisa. You did do some research. I love how you get onto these things so quickly. As Ian said at the beginning of his report, money is particularly tight in Tasmania with its small but spread population. I would hate to see Island disappear. I don’t read it much, but when I do I’m impressed by its quality.

    • Ian Broinowski permalink
      September 22, 2019 5:54 pm

      Hi Lisa,
      You are right self publishing is really challenging to get it into book shops. Fullers does know about it but trying to get them to stock it is challenging. You can buy it from Lulu.com for $30 plus post and it generally arrives in a few days.Or from Hobart bookshop for $50

      Thankyou for your interest and please contact me if you have any questions

      kindest regards Ian

      • September 23, 2019 8:50 am

        Again, thanks Ian for joining in, and clarifying the situation regarding availability of your book. Lulu seems to be a good service.

  7. September 17, 2019 5:23 pm

    Thanks for your response, Ian, much appreciated:) $55 is a bit outside my budget, but I’ll put the hard word on my library and see what they can do…
    I wonder if the Arts Council has a slush fund for bailing organisations out… (forgive my cynicism) they might be waiting to see if some philanthropist might stump up first…
    I know that all LitMags are in trouble because so few people subscribe to them these days, and some of them at least rely on university funding as well as State governments. But Tassie does seem like a special case to me. (In the past I’ve donated to their Writers Centre, which I don’t do even for my own Victorian one!)
    It just doesn’t seem fair to me.

    • September 17, 2019 6:10 pm

      I agree about fairness Lisa. I think too many people have a too-simplistic notion of what farness is.

  8. September 17, 2019 5:31 pm

    Lol

  9. September 18, 2019 8:57 am

    Interesting stuff. Here in America we do hear a little bit about Major Australian writers but we hear almost nothing about what is coming from Tasmania. A similar story is true regarding history. Few Americans know much about Tasmanian history. I am a history buff and I only know the barest essentials.

    • September 18, 2019 9:23 am

      Hey Brian, following on from the last bit of this report, have you tried Heather Rose’s The Museum of Modern Love? It’s brilliant.

    • September 18, 2019 11:59 am

      That’s understandable Brian. Just like we might know some general American history but not much about, say, Hawaii?

    • September 20, 2019 5:30 pm

      If you’d like to read Tasmanian history, Brian, you can’t go past James Boyce’s Van Diemen’s Land, if you can get it.

  10. Ian Broinowski permalink
    September 22, 2019 5:48 pm

    Thankyou so much for a well considered and thoughtful review. Ian Broinowski

    • Ian Terry permalink
      September 23, 2019 8:57 am

      You’re welcome, Ian, I enjoyed the conversation.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: