When my 2018 New Territory blogging mentee Amy (of The Armchair Critic) suggested that we do some sort of joint end-of-year blog post I loved the idea. The only question was what would we talk about, and how would we do it? It wasn’t too hard to decide former, as the subject matter was obvious: we would write about our favourites reads of this year, what we’d like to read over summer, and the ACT Writers Centre’s New Territory program which brought us together
As for how, we tossed around various formats, but settled on something simple: each of us would write a post responding to our agreed topics, and would then post the other person’s answers on our own blog. This means that you can read Amy’s responses below, and mine on Amy’s blog.
I do hope you enjoy Amy’s thoughts. We would both love to hear your comments on her reading.
Amy’s highlights
Best Fiction
I’ve managed to narrow it down to three. All of them happen to have won prizes but this is a coincidence; I take an interest in prizes but I don’t let my reading habits be defined by them. First up is Moon Tiger by Penelope Lively. This won the Booker Prize in 1987. It tells the story of Claudia, a journalist, who mentally revisits her life as she is dying. The fluidity of Lively’s prose reminds me of Virginia Woolf, and, like Woolf, it encapsulates multiple perspectives of the same event. It is a short book but extremely dense, though in a good way – it is emotionally and historically rich, spanning events throughout the twentieth century including the second world war.
My other favourite novel was The bookshop by Penelope Fitzgerald which coincidentally is also a previous Booker winner. I read it after seeing the movie, which I reviewed on my blog. I loved Fitzgerald’s witty turn of phrase and the sense of quiet devastation that her understated prose leaves you with. A hard-hitting meditation on justice, personal culpability and the cost of pursuing a life in art.
My final fiction read is The museum of modern love by Heather Rose which won the 2017 Stella Prize. This book centres around a performance work at MONA in New York by Marina Abramovic and weaves aspects of Abramovic’s life with the contemporary life of the protagonist, Arky Levin, whose wife is seriously ill. It explores themes including the purpose of art, and the nature of human connection.
Best Non-fiction
Again I have to pick the top three. First up is Murder without a motive by the Saturday Paper’s chief correspondent Mart McKenzie Murray. Murray investigates the murder of schoolgirl Rebecca Ryle in Perth’s northern suburbs in 2004, and how her family manages to live in the knowledge of what happened to her. Mckenzie-Murray and I both grew up in Perth’s northern suburbs around where the murder took place, so I identified strongly with his (not so flattering) evocations of it. What clinched the book for me was how Mckenzie-Murray explored how the life trajectory of Ryle’s murderer was conditioned by his stultifying surroundings which were characterised by toxic masculinity.
Next up is Draw your weapons by Sarah Sentilles. I heard Sentilles at this year’s Adelaide Writer’s Week, and I highly recommend these podcasts for summer listening. Sentilles, a pacifist and former art history professor, writes about the ethical entanglements we all have with our society’s violent structures, and how we can take both a moral and practical stand against being implicated in perpetuating such violence. The book is held together by the stories of two men; a conscientious objector from World War Two and a soldier who worked at Abu Graib. Saying a book changed your life can be a throwaway line, but in this case it is true.
Lastly is Small wrongs: How we say sorry in life, love and the law by Kate Rossmanith. Rossmanith is an academic with degrees in theatre and anthropology. The book is “hybrid,” as she examines remorsefulness and redemption in her own life, as well as in other spheres such as the law. Her writing is beautiful and she is brutally honest about her own actions, which is very compelling and refreshing. I literally could not put this book down.
Best biography
I reviewed Do oysters get bored by Rozanna Lilley for New Territory. Lilley is such a talented writer, and I enjoyed the way she teased out her complicated relationships with her parents and the artistic community she grew up surrounded by. As I wrote in my review, I really believe Lilley has done Australian society a major service by demonstrating the moral conundrums and aftermath of artists’ delusional or egocentric behaviour.
My other favourite was Twin by Allen Shawn. Shawn is a composer and musician whose father was William Shawn, the long-serving editor of the New Yorker. Like his father, Allen has many anxieties and phobias which he has also written about. Twin is an account of how Shawn’s autistic twin sister Mary was removed from the family at the age of five and has spent her life in an institution. The dynamics of Shawn’s family are complex – there is a major twist about his parents’ relationship, and it really demonstrates the extent to which self-deception and sacrifice, mostly on the part of mothers, are necessary to maintain a bearable home life. Shawn’s writing is poetic and devastating.
Highlights of my summer reading list
The life to come by Michelle de Kretser and No more boats by Felicity Castagna: I heard these two authors together at Adelaide Writers Week and am really looking forward to getting into their work
- The helpline by Katherine Collett: Collett is co-creator of the podcast The First Time and this is her first book. Apparently it is hilarious, and revolves around a mathematician who works on a senior citizens’ helpline …
- Shell by Kristina Olsson: set during the building of the Opera House, a building I am fascinated by. It is billed as a moving reflection on art and shame.
- Giving up the ghost by Hilary Mantel: I came across this while researching Mantel’s views on historical fiction for my first New Territory piece. It is about her relationship with her family history.
- Any ordinary day by Leigh Sales: I picked this up in a bookshop and was totally compelled by the first few pages.
What has New Territory meant to me?
New Territory has been great for many reasons. I’ve spent time with the amazing Sue Terry and have built relationships with the wonderful staff at the ACT Writers Centre, whose advice I really value. I’ve been exposed to rehearsals at The Street and have come to understand what it takes to produce theatre. I have attended some great events at the National Library, not to mention being able to speak to Rozanna Lilley courtesy of the Canberra Writers Festival.
From a craft point of view it was helpful to have the experience of being edited, and seeing how a good editor can really improve your work. I was also really privileged to attend the Hard Copy conference, where I heard from writers, agents and publishers about the publishing industry and how to get people to read your writing. This was invaluable, and helped me develop my goals for next year, which include pitching to a writers festival as a presenter, and networking with the writing community both online and at events.
Good luck with your writing career, Amy!
Thanks Lisa… I think she’s off to a good thoughtful start.
The only book you mention that I have read is The Museum of Modern Love which is certainly outstanding. If I could recommend one in turn it would be Rubik by Elizabeth Tan – which of course as a Western Australian you might already have read. Despite living in Perth for more than half of the last 40 years I had to look up (in the West) the murder of Rebecca Ryle – an interesting thesis that “the banality of the suburbs played a role in Rebecca’s death”.
I have this book Bill… Just got to find time to read it. Amy is from the west in fact so it will be interesting to see if she knows this book or story.
Amy’s best fiction list aligns exactly with mine.
That’s great Ztis. Amy should feel positive about that.
This is such an appealing list of books. I think that I would like to read them all. I tend to like both fiction and non fiction so both types of books interest me.
Murder Without a Motive sounds particularly painful. I believe that books need to show us the darker sides of existence. With that, as I get older I have been shying away from a few books that I think might be particularly disturbing.
I have read Moon Tiger which is an excellent novel. I would agree with you strongly that “short but extremely dense” shouldn’t put anyone off. A novel of quiet power with a sophisticated sense of the main character’s sense of history…must look up my copy!
I loved Moon tiger too, Ian. I happily read it again.
Thanks Brian. I agree that Amy’s choices are good ones.
What is it about aging, do you think, that causes this change re disturbing material?
Hi Brian. I also approach books with dark subject matter with apprehension. It took me a while to read Mckenzie-Murray’s book, but once I picked it up I couldn’t stop. It is uplifting in the sense that her parents are amazing, and have turned to kindness and love rather than bitterness and hate. I really encourage you to have a read 🙂
Thanks Amy for adding that. I guess the book is in the “true crime genre”, which can be pretty formulaic I understand, but can also be thoughtful and in that “creative nonfiction” vein. I quite enjoy that sort of true crime because it can, as you’ve implied, explore the greys in the story.
I’ve never really been interested in Penelope Lively but you have made me curious by saying she reminds you of Virginia Woolf. Now I am going to have to investigate! Is there a first book recommendation for her?
Why not inte in her Stefanie? Hopefully Amy will answer this as I’ve only read Moon tiger which like Amy I loved.
Hi Stefanie. To be honest I have only read Moon Tiger, but over the next few weeks I am hoping to read The Road to Lichfield. After that I will probably read Family Album, although, being an avid gardener myself, I am tempted by her non-fiction book Life In The Garden, which is a reflection on her own gardening experiences and gardens in literature.
I didn’t know you were an avid gardener Amy? Have you read Elizabeth von Arnim’s Elizabeth and her German garden. It is a treasure of a book.
I will have to read that!
Also Stefanie, in August Penelope Lively did a live web chat with The Guardian that you might be interested in https://www.theguardian.com/books/live/2018/jul/27/penelope-lively-webchat-post-your-questions-now
Thanks for this interesting and detailed list. And may 2019 be an even more fruitful year for you and all your book club, Janites, litblogger friends! Happy New Year, WG!
Thanks Arti. And the best of the New Year to you.