What I especially like about Jeanine Leane’s book, Purple threads, is how well she draws the universal out of the particular. That she does this is not unusual in itself. After all, this is what our favourite books tend to do. The interesting thing about Purple threads, though, is that the particular is an indigenous one. Even as I write this post my mind is flicking back-and-forth between thinking about the indigenous themes in the book and the more universal ones about family and relationships. More on that anon. First, I want to say a little about the book’s form, because ….
I’m not sure whether to call Purple threads a novel or a book of connected short stories, except I don’t think it matters much. What is significant is that the stories revolve around a mostly female-only indigenous family living on a small piece of land in the Gundagai area of New South Wales in the 1950s to 1960s. The main characters run through the whole book, and the stories are told pretty much chronologically. There could even be a plot line or two, but they are not strong and are not what drive us to read on. This form had an eerie familiarity as I was reading and I realised it was because it reminded me of another David Unaipon Award winning book I have reviewed here, Marie Munkara’s Every secret thing. Is this a coincidence – after all, there are similar books by non-indigenous writers – or should I go out on a limb and wonder whether this form reflects an indigenous way of story-telling? In addition to this similarity in form, these two books share a particular style of humour. Munkara’s is probably more belly-laugh, and is definitely more gut-wrenching, but both have a self-deprecating element, a willingness and ability to laugh at themselves, to see the absurd. It’s a form of humour we also see in Alexis Wright‘s Carpentaria. Okay, enough of that, back to the book itself.
The stories are told first person by Sunny (Sunshine) who lives with her sister Star, and her grandmother, Nan, and aunts, Boo (Beulah) and Bubby (Lily). Her mother, father, grandfather, more aunts and uncles, and others in the community, also appear in the book, but these five named characters are the focus. They are well differentiated. Nan is the down-to-earth matriarch of the group who doesn’t know how to read but “sure as hell know[s] how ta think”. Boo is independent and feisty, the one who takes action when action is needed. She loves the ancient Romans, particularly Empress Livia “who knew how to work behind the scenes”. Bubby, on the other hand, is the gentle, romantic one, who loves Emily Bronte and Wuthering Heights. The stories chronicle the first two decades of Sunny’s life in this female-dominated household. There are anecdotes about walks with Aunty Boo, about spoilt Petal (Sunny and Star’s mother), and about interactions with neighbours, teachers and others in the community. Most of the stories are light, albeit with a good degree of bite, but some are dark, such as the story of the young white neighbour, Milli, who is regularly beaten by her husband. This story, in fact, forms a minor plot line in part of the book.
The universal themes are about the way families comprise different and sometimes conflicting personalities and yet manage to love and support each other to ensure their joint survival. The particularity, though, has to do with being indigenous, with being lesser, in a rural community. Leane handles this cleverly, using, for example, the Christian symbol of “the black sheep” throughout the book to tease out the ironies and complexities packed into this idea when it is played out in a sheep-farming community. The symbol is explicitly introduced to us in “God’s flock” where Sunny talks about going to church and being taught the story of “the black sheep”:
‘ … But Jesus, if we pray to him [the priest says], will find all the lost sheep and return them to the fold, even the black sheep that no one else wants or loves.’
At least this bit made sense to us. Apart from Jesus, we didn’t know any other sheep farmer who loved black sheep. Most hated them, in fact. That’s why every year my Aunties always ended up with a few black lambs to raise ….
Leane shows how Nan and the Aunties navigate life in a world where “black was not the ideal colour” and in which “women livin’ by themselves are always easy targets”. They navigate it with dignity, often by pretending to go along with white society’s ways while staying true to their own values, which involve respecting and caring for other people and creatures and for their little bit of land.
Purple threads, apparently drawn from Leane’s life, provides an engaging but uncompromising insight into a life most Australians know little about. I hope I’m not being too pompous when I say that we need more books like this, and they need to be read by more people, if we non-indigenous Australians are to have a chance of truly appreciating the experience of being indigenous in our nation.
Read for ANZLitLovers Indigenous Literature Week, for which Lisa has also reviewed it.
St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 2011
(Review copy supplied by University of Queensland Press via ANZLitLovers blog giveaway. Thanks Lisa. Thanks UQP)
* I have assumed copyright permission for this cover on the basis that the book was provided by UQP
23 thoughts on “Jeanine Leane, Purple threads (Review for Indigenous Literature Week)”
I am so glad you liked it!
I’m interested in your thoughts about the form … I have wondered about this too, and whether it derives in part from memoir which is the most common form of indigenous writing at the moment?
Yes … I was thinking of suggesting that but the review was getting too long but I suspect this might be a strong strand in indigenous writing and may well have grown out of a long oral tradition of story-telling.she mentions more than once that the women would happily while away hours sitting around the hearth talking and reading, which seems suggests the significance and role of story.
I also wanted to talk about Gundagai, just for personal reasons.
It makes sense that an oral tradition of passing on stories would influence the way stories are written.
Yes, I think so … And there’s probably some theoretical analysis out there discussing it (methinks!
Pingback: Reviews from Indigenous Literature Week at ANZ Litlovers 2012 « ANZ LitLovers LitBlog
Sounds like a good book. Does the title have some significance?
Good question Stefanie, and one I thought about mentioning it in the review. It does. It’s about being different and accepting difference, and comes from Epictetus who spoke of being the bright purple thread in the toga that makes everything bright and beautiful rather than the threads that are like all the rest. He asks why are they telling him to be like other threads, and if he does make himself like that, how can he still be purple?
The colour purple features a lot in the landscape of that area and so appears frequently throughout the stories which nicely emphasises the point.
What a wonderful story! Epictetus pops up on my radar every now and then and he always sounds so very interesting. A lovely metaphor and it sounds like it ties in nicely to the book in more ways then one.
I should have included it in my review, Stefanie, because it does. She also dedicates her book to the “purple threads in my life”.
I don’t think you are being too pompous at all in wishing for a wider readership for contemporary indigenous literature. This book is on my list – it’s a world I’d like to read about, in an era I love. Plus my grandfather came from Gundagai!
OH did he, Catherine, then you’d love it because it’s very much a book of that place in terms of description (as well as being universal). (And thanks re the pomposity … I like to shy away from “shoulds” and “musts” but sometimes it seems appropriate.)
Not pompous at all. We absolutely need more novels giving voice to other perspectives and ways of being, thinking, feeling.
Thanks, Hannah, you’re right, we do.
Pingback: Purple Threads by Jeanine Leane: Book Review | Karenlee Thompson
It’s worth hearing her speak. She is an amazing lecturer and she inspired me to take more of an interest in Aboriginal narratives.
Welcome onehistorynerd. I love hearing personal experiences of writers, like yours. I heard Anita Heiss speak on the weekend and she was an amazing, inspiring speaker too and a good ambassador for indigenous stories. I must look out for an opportunity to hear Leane.
Pingback: 2012 AWW Challenge Wrap-up: Diversity « Australian Women Writers Challenge
Pingback: 2012 AWW Challenge Wrap-up: Diversity | Australian Women Writers Challenge
Pingback: Preview 2015 National Book Festival – Australian First Nations | Literary Birthdays Blog
Pingback: Preview 2015 National Book Festival – Culinary Arts | Literary Birthdays Blog
Pingback: Preview 2015 National Book Festival – Mystery and SciFi | Literary Birthdays Blog
Pingback: Preview 2015 National Book Festival – Fiction | Literary Birthdays Blog
Pingback: Complete Preview National Book Festival – Washington DC – September 5, 2015 | Literary Birthdays Blog