Nonfiction November 2022: Stranger than fiction

Week 3 of Nonfiction November (November 14-18) focuses on “all the great nonfiction books that almost don’t seem real. A sports biography involving overcoming massive obstacles, a profile on a bizarre scam, a look into the natural wonders in our world—basically, if it makes your jaw drop, you can highlight it for this week’s topic” and is hosted by Christopher (Plucked from the Stacks).

Last year, introducing my post on this week, I wrote that what the idea of “stranger than fiction” brings to my mind are those coincidences (and the like) that happen in real life that a fiction writer could never get away with. This week’s topic host, Christopher, though, takes a broader view, including things like “overcoming massive obstacles”, “scams” and “natural wonders”. My interpretation is a bit different again.

I’m starting with an essay I read via the Library of America’s Story of the Week program, James Weldon Johnson’s “Stranger than fiction” (my review). Johnson wrote one of those trickily titled novels, The autobiography of an ex-colored man (1912). It was inspired by his own experiences, and has been described as the first fictional memoir by a black person. Its protagonist is a young unnamed biracial man, who, because of such experiences as witnessing a lynching, decides to “pass” as white for safety and advancement reasons. The novel chronicles his experiences and ambivalent feelings about his decision.

In 1915, Johnson wrote his essay “Stranger than fiction” about his novel’s reception. To summarise what I wrote in my post, he basically found that for many Northern reviewers, the work was so “real” they could barely believe it was fiction, whereas Southern critics asserted that the work was unbelievable because, Johnson wrote, they didn’t believe African Americans could “pass” as “the slightest tinge of African blood is discernible, if not in the complexion, then in some trait or characteristic betraying inferiority.” For Johnson, this was “laughable”, as most people, he said, know of people who are “passing.”

There are so many “stranger than fiction” layers to this essay and situation but I will leave it here. This essay would, of course, have been another great Week 2 pairing for me with Nella Larsen’s Passing.

What can be stranger than families?

Families, of course, are the stuff of fiction, particularly unhappy ones (as Tolstoy famously shared), but they can also be found in non-fiction, particularly in memoirs, so here I’m going to share three families which were/are strange for one reason or another:

  • Alison Croggon’s Monsters: A reckoning (my review) chronicles a sister-relationship that went badly sour. It’s always sad – and yes, a bit strange to me – when families fall apart. The collapse of siblings relationships is particularly devastating I think.
  • Jane Sinclair’s Shy love smiles and acid drops (my review) chronicles the author’s parents’ difficult relationship. There is much that is “strange” here for most of us, starting with the family’s bohemian lifestyle.
  • Cindy Solonec’s Debesa: The story of Frank and Katie Rodriguez (my review) is strange in a different way. The relationship here is a positive and productive one, but the press release for the book makes its “strangeness” clear when it says the book is about “the unlikely partnership of Cindy’s parents: Frank Rodriguez, once a Benedictine novice monk from Spain, and Katie Fraser, who had been a novitiate in a very different sort of abbey – a convent for ‘black’ women at Beagle Bay Mission” (near Broome). Debesa is also a little strange in form as it is one of those hybrid biography-memoirs in which the writer is part of the family she’s focusing on.

None of these families are probably stranger than anything you’d find in fiction, but they do prove that the strange families you find in fiction can indeed be realistic!

For those of you doing Nonfiction November, I’ll see your strange offerings I’m sure, but, if you’re not, I’d love to see what strange nonfiction you’ve read.

26 thoughts on “Nonfiction November 2022: Stranger than fiction

  1. I once disguised a memoir piece as a fictional short story and the publisher said it was – unfortunately – unbelievable. One day, I might get to write it all, but I will have to fictionalise some of it to make it more likely. Ha!

  2. Oh, I’ve read several nonfiction works that were astounding, almost unbelievable:

    Sounds Like Titanic by Jessica Chiccehitto Hindman <<this one is a hoot

    Can You Ever Forgive Me? by Lee Israel <<this one made me hang my mouth open

    18 Tiny Deaths: The Untold Story of Frances Glessner Lee and the Invention of Modern Forensics by Bruce Goldfarb <<this one surprising because I thought there were more forensic pathologists

    Have You Found Her? by Janice Erlbaum << this one I would love to tell you about but do not want to spoil it.

  3. The only Stranger Than Fiction I’ve come across is the movie with Will Farrell and Emma Thompson. You’re right, families provide the strangest and craziest cases for fiction… August: Osage County comes to mind. I’ve also read and watched Passing, which I think is captivating. November is also Novella Month, in which I usually participate but not this year as I’m doing the Proust Centenary. Lots of reading activity in this month.

  4. BTW, just watched The Wonder on Netflix last night. What a strange movie but very well done. That’s the adaptation of the book by Emma Donoghue, who wrote the book and screenplay for Room. Florence Pugh is one star to watch!

  5. I love your take on this! I have to admit, I laughed at “What can be stranger than families?” Could not agree with you more!! I hadn’t heard of any of your suggestions, but I’m especially interested in Monsters. It sounds very complex and multi-layered but intriguing.

  6. Pingback: ≫ No ficción Noviembre de 2022: Más extraño que la ficción > Mejor Precio Online 2022

  7. Pingback: Nonfiction November Week 4: New to My TBR – What's Nonfiction?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s