Skip to content

Monday musings on Australian literature: Bookshops, 2017

September 4, 2017

It’s been sometime since I’ve talked about bookshops. I missed this year’s National Bookshop Day (now called Love Your Bookshop Day). However, I have been thinking about bookshops. After a flurry of closures, particularly of bookshop chains, in our town, things seem to have settled down. My local mall, in fact, went from losing its two stores, several years ago, to now having two stores again. And, our independent stores around town seem to be holding their own. Is this indicative of something positive happening?

Well, I came across a recent article in The Conversation which suggested that things aren’t as desperate as we were feeling a decade ago. The article, by Nathan Hollier, the Director of Monash Publishing, is titled “Love of bookshops in a time of Amazon and populism”. It opens with the following sentence:

There was genuine positivity at this year’s Australian Booksellers’ Association Conference in Melbourne in June. The mood was one of camaraderie and optimism at the sharing of good news.

How nice, eh?

I’ll come back to the article, but of course I wanted to find out more about this year’s Australian Bookseller’s Conference. I didn’t find a lot of substance – in my brief Google search – but I did find some advance notification which listed some of the topics to be discussed:

a session on strategies for sustainability; the launch of National Bookshop Day 2017; a session on how small and independent publishers can work with bookstores to offer customers ‘something different’; a panel on children’s bookselling; and sessions on the state of the industry, ‘analogue marketing’, stock mix, and issues affecting small businesses.

Interesting, particularly given Hollier’s statement that children’s booksales are doing particularly well. He also says that “store numbers have steadied in recent years and, as was reported at the conference, both independent and chain or franchise booksellers are expanding”. Hmm … the number of stores is stable but these stores are expanding.

Book Stack

(Courtesy: OCAL, from

However, as Hollier points out, there’s a new threat on the horizon, Amazon, which, as most Australian readers probably already know, has bought a big distribution site just outside of Melbourne. Local booksellers, says Hollier, will need to adjust (once again) in an environment “in which Amazon will likely reduce its delivery time and charges significantly. This will place downward pressure on book prices, and thus booksellers’ margins and capacity to survive.”

In the face of a megastore which can carry huge stock, local booksellers need, as they always have done, to carefully curate their holdings. They will also need to beef up extra services. “Community building will be the order of the day,” says Hollier. However, this curating is harder at a time when review pages in broadsheet newspapers are reducing, because these pages provide booksellers with “a degree of consensus as to what is important and valuable to read.” Certainly, in the heyday of newspaper review pages, our local bookshop would be inundated with requests for books which had been reviewed, particularly in the weekend lift-outs.

Hollier also discusses the challenge of lower prices, saying that:

The Productivity Commission doesn’t accept arguments in favour of maintaining price levels for some products in order to keep the costs of others down. But regulatory bodies have special challenges when confronted with large, diverse conglomerates, such as Amazon. It has the capacity to drop prices for products in one category (such as books) to maximise competitiveness, while the overall bottom line is propped up by more profitable parts of the business (such as Amazon Web Services).

He goes on to talk about the challenges for regulation when large firms follow “determined strategies of tax minimisation, aggressive use of IP and patent law, and sustained intransigence towards its workforce’s self-organisation and unionisation”.

Muse bookshop

Muse bookshop (before an event)

So, what can local booksellers do? Well, mainly it must be to continue that age-old strategy of customer service. They can stock the books their readers want, “curate” their collections (with new release shelves, local author shelves, genre highlight shelves, and so on), and, as I’m seeing increasingly in my area, offer more author events and talks. While for some readers, the cheapest book is all that matters, for others of us (and perhaps we are the lucky ones who can afford it), the experience of browsing beautiful bookshelves and talking with the owner (or staff) is worth the extra few dollars the books might cost. It feels good to support a bricks-and-mortar shop.

Anyhow, Hollier says that the bottom line is for people to have the desire and time (oh yes) to read. This desire, he says,

rests most powerfully on the belief that what one knows and says matters; that democracy, its public sphere, and reason, evidence and logic are the driving forces of one’s society.

Oh boy, isn’t this true! In this sense, he concludes, we get “the books and bookshops we deserve”. If this is so, then it seems that readers are turning things around, are showing that it is real bookshops that we want. May the current apparently positive state-of-play continue and grow, eh?

Have you noticed changes in the bookshop landscape in your neck of the woods?

22 Comments leave one →
  1. September 5, 2017 01:44

    No change where I live. There are no chains here in town and two used bookshops. Well three if you count the library shop. One shop is unpleasant to go into because the owner seems to think we are there to STEAL books which makes me wonder if she really wants to part with them…
    BTW have you read any Austen biographies?
    I’m reading BROWSE:The World in Bookshops. You’d love it.

    • September 5, 2017 07:58

      Oh, that’s a shame, Guy. Is it just an Australian phenomenon. Will be interesting to see what others say.

      Yes, I’ve read a couple. Any reason you ask?

      Never heard of Browse… But the title is great for a start.

      • September 5, 2017 10:21

        Thinking of reading one and I wondered if you had a recommendation

        • September 5, 2017 17:58

          Probably the best regarded one, still, is Claire Tomalin’s Jane Austen: A life. It’s nearly 20 years old but I think it still holds its own, and is still pretty easily available I believe.

        • September 6, 2017 00:55

          Ok that’s the one I was leaning towards. Tx

        • September 6, 2017 08:12


  2. daveyone1 permalink
    September 5, 2017 05:08

    Reblogged this on World4Justice : NOW! Lobby Forum..

  3. ablay1 permalink
    September 5, 2017 07:55

    Interesting changes happening. Thanks for the links!

  4. September 5, 2017 08:18

    I live in Castlemaine where there are two main bookshops and several second-hand (that’s another thing) bookshops. The two main ones are Books Plus which is tiny and elegant, where you can get a range of lovely discounted books, and Stoneman’s which deserves its own sentences. So – Stoneman’s is unique and eccentric. It rambles through an old shop that once was a grocery store. The wide counter is the same one that used to offer cheese and ham. Currently, one of the tables is devoted to fabulous Taschen books which you can drool over (not literally, this is a civilised place). There are more flashy cook books here than I have ever seen in one place anywhere else. The latest fiction, all the children’s books you would ever want – this is getting too long for a comment. It is worth visiting Castlemaine just to see Stoneman’s. Rave rave.

    • September 5, 2017 09:44

      Thanks for giving Stonemason’s a plug Carmel. I must get to Castlemaine on one of our Victorian road trips.

      And yes, second hand shops are worth praising too – and I have written about them before. I have a couple of go-tos for Aussie lit.

  5. September 5, 2017 10:09

    I think I’ll move to Castlemaine! I’m not sure the inner southern suburbs of Perth have as many bookshops. But a big shout out to Crow books in Vic Pk. I’d retire to a bookshop of my own if I had the courage to believe customers would come.

    • September 5, 2017 13:39

      Hmmm, I responded to this via my iPad app, Bill, but I don’t think it’s “taken”. Anyhow, thanks for the shout-out to Crow Books (wherever Vic Pk is!!). I’m glad to give book shops loved my readers here a little plug.

  6. September 5, 2017 12:00

    Stoneman’s is a beautiful book shop. My little town supports two bookshops – one sells new books, the other sells secondhand books – but I truly don’t know how either keeps financially afloat. They both also compete with the newsagent and the op shops in town. There’s quite a bit of tourist trade though, and maybe that’s what does the trick. Just about every little town in the region has it’s own bookshop, so someone must be buying! I think bookshops will exist in the longer term but, just like saddleries, there will likely be fewer of them.

    • September 5, 2017 13:40

      Thanks Michelle. That’s great that you have two. They must be getting some customers if they’re surviving.

      Clearly, I must check out this Stoneman’s.

  7. ian darling permalink
    September 5, 2017 18:52

    Really good news that Australian independents are able to thrive – you give a daunting list of the challenges they face. Scottish independents are competing in the same imaginative ways- a shop like Golden Hare in Edinburgh or the Orcadian Bookshop outstanding examples.

  8. Meg permalink
    September 5, 2017 19:35

    I have to go into Melbourne to find good book shops. Local ones are small, and do not have a very good range. Hill of Content Bookshop at the top of Bourke Street is my favourite. I love to haunt second hand book shops and also op shops. You can find some real treasures in them.

    • September 6, 2017 08:11

      Oh yes I, remember Hill of Content from years ago Meg. You’re right about secondhand shops.

  9. September 6, 2017 03:11

    Our capital city used to have three bookshops plus a bundle of used stores. Now we’re down to one branch of a chain, an independent second hand shop and an Oxfam book shop. None of them are expanding their footprint however. The chain is doing a lot of author events and introduced a cafe but they are also selling ‘stuff’ like calendars and wrapping paper which I hate seeing.

    • September 6, 2017 08:15

      Oh yes, a lot of bookshops here, chains and independents, sell other stuff too. Cards, notebooks, and the like. I guess if they need to do it to survive, it’s better than not surviving?

      • September 7, 2017 08:56

        I understand the economic reasons but just wish they didn’t have to dilute the book buying experience and would use the space for more books

        • September 7, 2017 09:37

          Yes, fair enough though some of the independent shops do it very well. I bought an Emma brooch or pin, at a couple in the US.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: