Skip to content

Adam Thompson, Born into this (#BookReview)

July 9, 2021

When my brother gave me Tasmanian author Adam Thompson’s Born into this earlier this year, I told him I’d save it for Lisa’s ILW 2021, which I did – and which means I can now thank him properly for a yet another well-chosen gift, because this is a strong, absorbing and relevant read. If you haven’t heard of Thompson, as I hadn’t, he is, says publisher UQP, “an emerging Aboriginal (pakana) writer from Tasmania”. 

Born into this is a debut collection of sixteen short stories about the state’s Palawa/Pakana people, and based primarily in Launceston and islands in the Bass Straight. It reminds me a little of Melissa Lucashenko’s novel Too much lip (my review) because, like it, these stories are punchy, honest interrogations into the experience of being Indigenous in contemporary Australia. I say contemporary Australia, because most of the stories deal with recognisably First Nations Australia concerns. However, the collection is also particularly Tasmanian – in setting and in dealing with issues and conditions specific to that place.

They may live in two worlds, but they are still mob (“The old tin mine”)

I like to think about the order in which stories in a collection are presented, although I can never be confident of the assumptions I make about the reasoning. How can I, I suppose, as I’m not in the heads of the authors and their editors. The first story here, “The old tin mine”, is an interesting choice: it introduces various issues and ideas which are picked up through the collection and it sets a sort of resigned tone. The issues include the relationship between black and white in Australia, the introduction of city Indigenous kids to country and culture, the clumsy conscientiousness of white people who want to do the right thing, the politics involved, and the world-weariness of older Indigenous people in dealing with all of this. The story is told first person through the eyes of “Uncle Ben”, the Indigenous leader on an “Aboriginal survival camp”. He is tired, and cynical, and not particularly interested in dealing with these

Aboriginal teens. City boys. Three from Launceston, three from Hobart. “Fair split, north and south”, according to the organisation that had won the black money.

But it’s a job, and these jobs are becoming less frequent, so he takes it on.

The second story, “Honey”, is told third person, and concerns the interactions between white man Sharkey, who has a honey business, and his Palawa employee, Nathan. Sharkey is arrogant, condescending and oblivious of how his behaviour might affect Nathan. He asks Nathan for the “Aboriginal word for honey” because he thinks using it to brand his honey would “be a good gimmick for selling honey … ‘specially with the tourists”. Not all stories work out this way, but in this one, Nathan has the last laugh.

“Honey” also introduces another idea that peppers the collection, which is land rights, and non-indigenous Australians’ fear of losing land. The collection, in fact, references many of the issues confronting contemporary Australia’s relationship with its First Nations peoples: land rights; Invasion Day (or “change the date”); dispossession, the loss of Indigenous culture and attempts to reclaim it; social issues like incarceration, alcoholism and suicide among Indigenous people; and the Stolen Generations, to name some of them.

Some stories, however, respond to a particular Tasmanian issue, that regarding the definition of indigenity. As I wrote in my post on Kathy Marks’ Channelling Mannalargenna, Tasmania’s history has resulted in a specific set of circumstances regarding loss of identity, which has caused, and is still causing, complications and conflict over Indigenous identification in the state. One of the stories on this subject is “Descendant” about a bright, politicised but ostracised young schoolgirl who runs her school’s ASPA (Aboriginal Students and Parents) committee. Dorothy is assiduous about who is and is not “P-A-L-A-W-A”, and has family-tree records to prove it. Aboriginality, she says, is about “being”, not “choosing”. The story provides an excellent example of Thompson’s use of imagery to underpin his themes: Dorothy’s prized mug is accidentally broken, and Cooper, the supportive (of course!) librarian, tries to repair it, but

Bold, white cracks now intersected the Aboriginal colours like a tattered spider web.

Thompson’s writing in this collection is accessible but evocative. His dialogue varies appropriately from speaker to speaker, and the imagery, particularly that regarding colour – red, blue and white, representing white Australia, versus the red, black and orange of First Nations Australia’s flag – is pointed but not overdone. Thompson clearly knows his country. His descriptions of the islands, and the plants and birdlife endemic to them, take you there (or, at the very least, teach you about them.)

I would love to write about more of the collection’s stories, but I should leave you some surprises. I will say, though, that Thompson’s wide cast of characters – from young, disaffected palawa to smart activists, from genuine white people, who want to understand, to the smug and/or rich ones (as in the incisive “The black fellas from here“) – ensures that this collection hits home. No reader, really, can hide from the truths here because they touch us all.

White makes you wary (“Aboriginal Alcatraz”)

Born into this, then, is clearly political, but it is not all bleak. Some stories end with a bang or a twist, which skewer their points home, while others are more gentle. The title story, “Born into this“, is one of the more poignant ones. It tells of Kara, who works as a receptionist at an Aboriginal housing co-op. She’s jaded. Her boss is “a tick-a-box Aboriginal” who “could never prove his identity”, and she is tired of the struggle to survive. So, deep in the forest, where she had learnt about country from her uncle, she spends her spare time working away on her own quiet, little subversive project, a project that involves

Natural survivors, like her own family, born into a hostile world and expected to thrive. She took in the surrounding devastation and thought again about her own life.

“Born into this”.

She knows she won’t make a difference, but “fulfilling some cultural obligations in her own small, secret way” keeps her sane.

It would be great to think that books like Born into this could make a difference – and I think they could, if we all not only listened to Indigenous writers like Thompson, but also took on board, really took on board, what they tell us about ourselves.

For more reviews of this novel, please click Lisa’s ILW 2021 link in this post’s opening paragraph.

Adam Thompson
Born into this
St Lucia: UQP, 2021
210pp.
ISBN: 9780702263118

27 Comments leave one →
  1. July 10, 2021 00:42

    Will you forgive me if I say I will hold my comments until I get home and read it (no doubt finding the person who gave it to me as thoughtful as the person who gave it to you).

  2. July 10, 2021 00:52

    Ooooh, Sue, I love this review. I’m glad you mentioned Lucashenko’s book, because I loved that one. Part of the connection I made with Too Much Lip was recognizing modern problems because I’m alive, too, but then the history the main character shares about her family, the river they swim in, fighting the rich white guy trying to bulldoze things (in the 1990s, American kids were super aware of the “rich white boss” who wanted to bulldoze/demolish/pollute thanks to a number of environmentally-conscious cartoons). But this collection sounds even better, given the way different characters talk about history, culture, identity, etc. and have mixed opinions. I’m going to see if I can get this one!

    • July 10, 2021 03:48

      If you loved Too much lip, Melanie (as I know you did), and you love short stories, then I am sure you would enjoy this. I hope you can get it.

      • July 10, 2021 04:08

        I do love short stories! One of the benefits (but also downfalls) of attending an MFA program in fiction writing is that you deal almost exclusively with short stories and learn to carefully discern which are good.

        • July 10, 2021 11:17

          I thought you did – so many don’t that it’s pretty easy to remember those who do. I’d love even more for you to read this now, to see what you think. Let me know if you can’t find it and really would like it.

        • July 11, 2021 10:28

          Will do. Thank you, Sue!

        • July 11, 2021 10:31

          Okay, totally wild. I just learned that Thompson’s book will be released in the U.S. on July 31st from this indie publisher called Two Dollar Radio. They put out some interesting stuff. Case in point, they have a tattoo club!

        • July 11, 2021 10:33

          Oh that’s do good Melanie…. For you, for him, for Auslit.

  3. July 10, 2021 06:52

    Great review; a new writer to me and one I’ll look out for. Tasmania is a favourite part of Aus for me so I’m glad to know that there is work from its First Peoples being published and read.

    • July 10, 2021 11:18

      Thanks Denise. My brother lives in Tasmania so regularly sends me books by writers there, but I think this is the first Indigenous writer he’s sent. (He’ll correct me if I’m wrong!!)

  4. Meg permalink
    July 10, 2021 07:28

    Hi Sue, I read Born Into This, and was very impressed, and I loved the dark “Honey” story. I just finished another great reads of short stories by Indigenous writers in First Nation Stories Then and Now, edited by Ellen Van Neerven, and it has the same Adam Thomson story in this collection.

    • July 10, 2021 11:20

      Oh great Meg. “Honey” was really well done wasn’t it. I love that Van Neerven chose it for that collection. I might look out for it. I’ve read a bit of her – including another anthology she put together. She’s a great asset to Australian literature I think, as a writer across several forms, and as an editor and mentor.

  5. July 10, 2021 11:24

    Great review, Sue. I agree about the first story setting the tone and themes of what lays ahead. I think it’s a collection that invites a reread because I’m sure there are things I missed first time around.

    • July 10, 2021 11:55

      Thanks kimbofo. I agree. I could certainly reread it. I’d also love to share more from it, because it is so rich is the issues it covers and the way he shows not tells. It’s not didactic by there are certainly things he wants us to see, aren’t there?

  6. July 10, 2021 18:09

    I often wonder how life would be if all the indigenous peoples of our country received the same education as do all the later-comers ..

    • July 10, 2021 18:54

      Fair question M-R. That is certainly part of the issue. It would, though, have to be in a completely respectful environment and be an education that is relevant and respectful, wouldn’t it?

  7. July 10, 2021 18:32

    Wonderful review of this great collection Sue. I found the diversity of characters and story-types exciting. I’ve already passed my book onto a friend, otherwise I’d send it to Mel.

    • July 10, 2021 18:55

      Yes, I agree Brona. I liked that there was even that slightly futuristic one, “Your own Aborigine”. What a story that was.

  8. Ian Terry permalink
    July 11, 2021 20:55

    I’m glad that you enjoyed the book, Sue. I think it’s strength, apart from the evocative and unsentimental writing is that it is so strongly a palawa voice. For me this is a collection that is so clearly borne of lived experience on this island.

    • July 11, 2021 21:02

      Thanks Ian. I like the word “unsentimental” to describe it. And it certainly feels very Tasmanian from what I know of Tasmania through you and other reading I’ve done. I’m very glad you gave it to me. And, I didn’t say this in the post, but it’s a really nicely designed book too.

  9. buriedinprint permalink
    July 17, 2021 07:31

    “She knows she won’t make a difference, but “fulfilling some cultural obligations in her own small, secret way” keeps her sane.”

    This reminds me of a documentary film I watched last month for the work I’ve been doing on the climate crisis called “There’s Something in the Water” wherein the Mi’kmaq community was struggling to half the runoff from a paper plant directly into their waterway; the conviction to honour their culture seemed to keep these women (of all ages) going, day by day, resisting these genocidal practices and just dong a little bit and another little bit to try to make a change. And this in a part of what is now called Canada that is supposedly very community oriented and small-town and loving rocks and trees and water, and all of that–but these Indigenous women stood alone. Here’s a link for anyone interested and it’s currently streaming on Netflix:
    https://www.indiewire.com/2020/03/theres-something-in-the-water-netflix-review-ellen-page-1202221020/

Trackbacks

  1. Sunday Lowdown #127 – Grab the Lapels
  2. Reviews from Indigenous Literature Week at ANZ Litlovers 2021 | ANZ LitLovers LitBlog
  3. Born in to This, Adam Thompson | The Australian Legend

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: